A recent article that appeared in the Herald-Tribune in Sarasota Florida reported on the results of a recent poll of SBA lenders. The specific poll was to get feedback on a recent SBA memorandum (Viewable here) but the reported comments were fascinating.
It “scares me to death,” is one lender’s response.
Another said, “At a time when SBA is looking to promote small business lending programs, the issuance of this notice will call into question continued participation”.
Multiple Personality Disorder
Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) is defined as a disorder “whereby two or more distinct and separate personalities are manifested within the same individual, each displaying different interests and behavior patterns.” Today, the credit industry has two distinct personalities, often in conflict with each other.
On the one hand, there is a big push to extend credit. The federal government has been pumping money into the system for months now and the prime rate is lower than it’s been since WWII. On the other hand, regulators are on the lookout for anything that remotely resembles a return to the types of industry practices that contributed to getting us where we are today. The memorandum referenced above includes ominous sections entitled, “Strengthening Oversight of 7(A) Lenders” and “Identifying and Recovering Improper Payments”. Banks are looking for deals to fund, but many seem afraid to do so.
As a result, many transactions that make very good sense from traditional credit point of view are frozen in their tracks. Many credit officers, understandably, would rather turn down a good transaction rather than risk the consequences of a ‘bad loan’.
At InSource, the essence of our business is finding quality lenders/underwriters for our clients. A few years ago, as lenders were chasing down high yield, real estate backed securities, we had more customers than we had underwriters. Now, not a day goes by where I don’t get calls from an underwriter asking me to send them business. “We have money to lend”, they say. The problem is in the underwriting.
Every lender has an “appetite”. Some like certain types of transactions and others like different types of transactions. The days where common sense prevailed and underwriters were willing to do things “outside the box” seem to be only a memory. In fact, many underwriters want to stay right in the middle of the box.
The Treatment
The accepted treatments for MPDs are wide and varied. In this case, we can start by having realistic expectations on both sides. Borrowers need to understand that the days of 3% unsecured money for start up companies aren’t here anymore. Lenders need to understand that they are in the business of taking appropriate, mitigated risk. If we can meet in the middle, everyone will be OK.
I’d welcome your thoughts and your feedback.